|
An Innovative Cancer Course in Philadelphia
In
In
November, I will help teach a course on complementary and alternative
approaches to cancer at the Center for Integrative Medicine (CIM) in
Philadelphia. The CIM is part of Thomas Jefferson University Hospital and
Thomas Jefferson University. The course will begin after lunch on Friday,
November 16, and then proceed all day on Saturday, November 17, 2001. We hope
to enlist the help of Philadelphia oncologists and other medical specialists to
make this innovative course a big success. We have also applied for Continuing
Education credit for attendees.
At
this writing, the course is still in the planning phase. But during these two
days, we intend to intensively cover many topics of great interest to medical professionals who are
interested in the CAM treatment of cancer. Some of the likely topics are: an
overview of the field, and of the involvement of the NIH and NCI in CAM
research; the use of popular supplements such as antioxidants and their
interaction with chemotherapy; a discussion of mistletoe, and other botanicals
and immune modulators in cancer treatment; the use of anti-angiogenic agents in
the CAM context; breast cancer and soy isoflavones; polysaccharides and
medicinal mushrooms; hyperthermia as a "fourth modality" of cancer
treatment; PC SPES and other new treatments for prostate cancer; and some of
the psychological and spiritual dimensions of cancer care. For details on registration please contact Sharifa Pettigrew at the Center for Integrative Medicine at
Thomas Jefferson University Hospital 215 503-0720 or email
sharifa.pettigrew@mail.tju.edu
The Marienlyst Conference
This
summer I had the pleasure of attending the Seventh International Symposium for
Biologically Closed Electric Circuits in Biomedicine. This important meeting
was held at the Marienlyst Conference Center in Helsingør (Elsinore), a city
north of Copenhagen best known in the setting of Shakespeare's Hamlet.
The
meeting was sponsored by the International Association for Biologically Closed
Electric Circuits in Biomedicine (IABC). The local sponsor was Finn Scøtt
Andersen, MD, medical director of the nearby Humlegaarden cancer clinic. My
wife and I stayed at Humlegaarden for eight days and so got a better understand
of the workings of this unique healing community. The inquisitive spirit of
Finn Andersen shaped every aspect of the conference, especially the lively and
inquisitive atmosphere regarding all new cancer treatments.
The
IABC promotes the use of harmless low-level electrical currents and magnetic
fields in the treatment of cancer, neurological disorders, and other diseases.
The group had an unusually genesis. Although the current leadership is mainly
American (Prof. George O'Clock, Ph.D of Minnesota State and Carl F. Firley,
B.S.) the association originated with the Swedish scientist, Björn E.W.
Nordenström, MD, and his Chinese colleagues.
Dr.
Nordenström is the inventor of the skinny needle biopsy used all over the world
to diagnose cancer; he was also one of the pioneers of balloon catheterization
for heart disease. At one time, he chaired the Nobel Prize committee that
awarded the biology/medicine award.
In
the 1970s, he began to experiment with the effects of low level electrical
currents on the human body and published a scholarly book on the subject. He
developed a new approach to treating cancer which is known today as
electrochemical therapy, or ECHT. His clinical results in Sweden were
remarkable. In November, 1980 New York magazine published a a
three-part, front-page series on his work. What followed, however, was not
universal acclaim but the unreasonable rejection of his ideas by various
orthodox medical authorities.
Undeterred,
Prof. Nordenström took his treatment to the People's Republic of China, which
is more open to innovative approaches. Professor Xin Yu-Ling, director of
thoracic surgery at the China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing, welcomed the
chance to work with this world-famous scientist. Their collaboration began in
Beijing in 1987 and the IABC was then formed {Eur J
Surg Suppl 1994;574:7-23}. Under the direction of Prof. Xin, more than
10,000 cancer patients were treated {Eur J Surg
Suppl. 1994;574:25-29}. The treatment is now fully accepted by the
Chinese Medical Association and there are more than 300 Chinese members of the
IABC. About two dozen of these colleagues attended the meeting in Helsingør. In
addition, there are about 200 associates in Europe and another 100 in the US
and South America. (For more information about joining this important
organization readers should contact Carl Firley at iabc.adelphia.net).
There
were also participants from South Korea, where ECHT has recently been
introduced into an 800-bed hospital and from Alexandroupolis, Greece, where the
treatment of neurological disorders using ECHT is well underway. Members from
about a dozen other countries were also represented at the conference. So
"international" in the title is more than wishful thinking.
Complementary Medicine Section
Piggybacked
onto the IABC meeting was a concurrent session on more general complementary
approaches to cancer. I had the pleasure of chairing most of this section, and
I will mainly describe this part of the meeting.
The
conference began with a lucid presentation by Josef Beuth, MD. Dr. Beuth is the
director of a unique institute at the University of Cologne for the scientific
study of naturopathic medicine. He is also president of the German Society of
Oncology. Dr. Beuth the increasing evidence for the positive effects of
complementary therapies in oncology: his own work has focused on the biological
effects of lectins derived from the mistletoe plant.
This
was followed by an outstanding talk by Dr. Hinrich Peters on the use of
dendritic cell therapy in cancer. Dr. Peters is professor in the Department of
Immunology at the University of Gottingen, Germany. Dendritic cells are the
latest development in the century-old quest to find effective immune approaches
to cancer.
Johan
Haux, MD, an oncologist at Trondheim University Hospital in Norway, spoke about
his work with digitalis in the treatment of cancer. He is optimistic that
clinical trials using digitalis derivatives should begin in Norway soon.
There
were fascinating presentations by Chinese doctors on the use of traditional
Chinese formulas in treating cancer. Dr. Gan Zhong Liu spoke about the use of
"jinlong capsules" as cancer therapy. These are mixtures of amino
acids from various animal species. Dr. Liu Tong Qing of Beijing gave a detailed
presentation, complete with x-ray documentation, on treating cancer with a
combination of copper, iron and Chinese herbs.
This
presentation stimulated a great deal of discussion, since in the West most
scientists believe that both copper and
iron stimulate cancer growth and should be avoided. Yet some Chinese
scientists are using them, at high doses, as cancer treatments. How can
these two opposing views be reconciled? Dr. Andersen suggested that Dr. Liu
stay in Denmark long enough to clear up this intriguing difference. But perhaps
it will take a visit to China and many discussions to figure out this apparent
contradiction.
Next
came a discussion by Wolfgang Schmidt, MD, a radiation therapist from
Greifswald, Germany, on the effectiveness of mistletoe in cancer. Michael
McCulloch, L.Ac., an acupuncturist at the Pine Street Medical Education and
Research Group in San Anselmo, Calif., spoke about the use of the meta-analysis
technique in clinical research. He also wowed the conference with his flawless
speaking ability in Chinese. After dinner, the celebrated German alternative
practitioner, Wolfgang Scheef, MD, gave a presentation on the use of
proteolytic enzymes in the treatment of cancer. It was a wide-ranging speech,
delivered in his charismatic style. It was good to see that he had overcome the
effects of a recent illness and was "back in action."
On
the next day, we heard from Steen Lindkjaer Jensen, MD, a Danish
gastrointestinal surgeon who also works at the Hammersmith Hospital, London, on
his use of radiofrequency ablation (RFA) in the treatment of liver metastases.
His conclusions were seconded by Bjorn Skjoldby, MD, of the Herlev University
Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark. From these, I gained the impression that
multiple liver metastases can often be eliminated with radio waves when surgery
is no longer feasible.
Antioxidants and Cancer
Dr.
Joseph Brenner, chief of oncology at Wolfson Hospital, Israel, followed with a
presentation on the treatment of cancer using hyperthermia without radiation
and chemotherapy. My own presentation was on whether or not dietary
antioxidants interfere with chemotherapy and radiation. I presented some new
data, theories and controversies that have emerged since the publication of my
book, Antioxidants Against Cancer (2000). I concluded that the evidence
supporting concurrent use is stronger today than ever before (My speech can be
found at www.cancerdecisions.com/denmark2001.html).
Michael
Christiansen, MD, from the Danish Serum Institute in Copenhagen, ably
reviewed various tumor markers in
cancer, particularly "Her-2-neu." This led logically to a discussion on the use
of Herceptin in the treatment of Her-2-neu positive breast cancer patients by
Filip Janku, MD. Dr. Janku, just 27 years old, is a rising star of the oncology
department at Charles University Hospital in Prague, Czech Republic. He
projected a very positive impression of Herceptin. This led to a lively
exchange on this topic with Josef Beuth, MD and Dieter Hager, MD of the BioMed
clinics in Germany.
On
the third and final day of the conference Dr. Finn Andersen spoke on
angiogenesis. He stated that angiogenesis should always be taken into account
in cancer treatment. In his own clinic, he has begun to apply the lessons
taught by Judah Folkman, MD of Harvard University. Harald Schmidt, MD, of
Denmark presented his results with one kind of anti-angiogenesis treatment,
thalidomide, used to treat advanced cancer.
Ray
Rosenthal, MD, a physician from Hawaii, related his own experiences with
cancer. Initially, he tried to treat
his own lymphoma with immune-stimulating substances. This was unsuccessful. He
then discovered Dr. Scheef and had a very positive response. He is now without
signs of the disease and is writing a book on the remarkable Dr. Scheef.
Finally,
Mark Atkinson, MD, vice president of the Complementary
Medical Association (CMA), spoke about an exciting pain relieving
technology, low-dose electrical currents called ACE.
Overall,
an enormous number of new ideas were discussed at this meeting. Not long ago, a
serious discussion of complementary treatments was impossible. Most reputable
scientists were afraid to associate themselves with anything smacking of "alternative
medicine." How times change! The
impressive academic credentials of the speakers at Marienlyst is ample proof
that CAM is increasingly seen as a promising way of helping cancer patients.
Thanks
to open-minded and energetic physicians, such as Dr. Finn Andersen, a true
integration of conventional and non-conventional cancer treatments is slowly
taking place. Orthodox scientists now frequent CAM conferences, and CAM
practitioners present papers at the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO).
The discussion at conferences such as this one help to create a common
vocabulary that easily slips back and forth between Herceptin and hyperthermia,
colonics and chemotherapy.
The
world of cancer owes a debt of gratitude to the IABC for facilitating this
international discussion. It allowed scientists of various nationalities,
specialties and perspectives to exchange ideas on how to best treat cancer.
Many new collaborative friendships were made. I came away more convinced than
ever that CAM has an important role to play in the ultimate conquest of this
disease.
Flaxseed and Cancer
A
well-known oncologist Charles Myers, MD, has cautioned against the use of
flaxseed by prostate cancer patients (www.vegsource.com). But recently a pilot
study suggested that flaxseed, in conjunction with a low-fat diet, may have a
protective effect against the disease. The July report came from scientists at
Duke University Medical Center (Urology 2001;58:47-52).
Twenty-five
men awaiting surgery for prostate cancer consumed a low-fat diet as well as
three tablespoons per day of finely-ground flaxseed. The researchers measured
their prostate-specific antigen (PSA), testosterone and cholesterol levels. The
men followed this regimen for 34 days before undergoing their scheduled
surgery. They were then compared to historic controls.
Both
testosterone and cholesterol levels decreased. The PSA level was decreased in
those with early-stage disease. According to Wendy Demark-Wahnefried, "For the
men on the diet, their tumors cells did not divide as quickly and there was a
greater rate of apoptosis [i.e., programmed cell death] in this group."
While
not conclusive, this suggests that the combination of flaxseed and low-fat diet
not only lowers cholesterol but might be beneficial for some men with
early-stage prostate cancer.
|